pdaaaa畢業(yè)論文心得分享我的投稿經(jīng)歷-酸甜苦辣-資料下載頁
2025-08-04 10:07本頁面
【正文】 e calculations are more precise than earlier calculations. To justify this claim they pare their data with experimental values, see Fig. 5 b). But the experimental values used are very limited and only for large pinched off channels. This claim is not justified by using only these data! The quantized current is calculated for a splitgate device. Then at the very end, experimental data of an etched device is presented: this does not fit together. The potential landscape in an etched device is different from a split gate device. Why do the authors not calculate such a device? Then, experimental and theoretical data would fit together. So either the claim that their method of calculation is better needs to be more solid, or the experimental and theoretical data needs to fit together. finally, the language needs some improvement (a lot of prepositions are missing)審稿人的意見很中肯，于是，我按照審稿人的意思，把文章又仔仔細細地改了一遍，補充了實驗數(shù)據(jù)。刪掉了最后一個與我們計算的器件不是對應的實驗圖，增加了一篇參考文獻。其中還改了里面的英語表達。修改完成后，給審稿人的修改說明竟然有四頁，呵呵。修改完成，馬上投過去，這次更快，速度快得驚人，當時還把我嚇出了冷汗。不信就看看吧Manuscript Sent to Production20090511 13:03:17 Decision Sent20090511 13:03:17 Decision Letter Being Prepared20090508 14:35:22 Editorial Evaluation Editor20090508 13:31:50 Under Review20090507 13:47:23 Securing Reviewer(s)20090507 11:15:56 Under Consideration Editorial Office20090507 11:15:55 AuthorApproved Files Submitted20090507 10:14:15 Under Consideration Editorial Office20090507 10:14:15 AuthorApproved Files Submitted20090507 10:14:14 Awaiting Author Adjustment/Approval of Converted Files20090507 09:57:41 Manuscript Files Uploaded20090507 09:53:40 Preliminary Manuscript Data Posted20090507 09:29:22從投出去到審稿結束僅僅一天！五月十二號收到編輯的信Dear : I am pleased to inform you that your manuscript, referenced below, has been accepted for publication in the Journal of Applied Physics. Materials are being prepared for AIP Production Services.Reviewer Comments: Reviewer 1 Evaluations: RECOMMENDATION: Publish as is Sufficient New Physics in an Applied Area: Yes Appropriate Length: Yes Well Organized and Clearly Written: Yes Good Title: Yes Good Abstract: Yes Clear Figures: Yes Adequate References: Yes TECHNICAL QUALITY RATING: Good PRESENTATION RATING: Good Reviewer 1 (Comments to the Author): The authors have significantly improved the manuscript and therefore a submission is now justified.從意見看，審稿人對我的修改非常滿意！呵呵！經(jīng)歷了坎坎坷坷，終于接收。在這里我還真得感謝小木蟲，感謝蟲子們對我的幫助和鼓勵，在這里我學到了很多有關投稿寫作的經(jīng)驗。越挫越勇，不言放棄，就是成功！謝謝大家！
數(shù)學相關推薦
鄂ICP備17016276號-1