【正文】 thatitnolongermakessensetocontinuetowardspublication– Evenafterpublication,asituationmayarisewherebyitmakessensetowithdrawastandardProposed resolution? 88021shouldspecifythatboth802ISO/IEChaveavetoofanydecisiontopublishanstandardasan8802xstandard? 88021shouldalsospecifyboth802ISO/IEChavetherighttowithdrawan8802xstandardafterpublication– egitmightmakesensetowithdrawa8802xstandardifanamendmentwasvetoed,onthebasisthat802wouldnolongerbeabletomaintainthestandard– Appropriatenoticewouldberequiredforanywithdrawaltotakeeffect? ItisassumedthatexercisingtheserightswouldbeexercisedonlyafterverycarefulconsiderationofthecircumstancesConclusion–802VetoSeptember202322 AndrewMyles(Cisco)doc:IEEESubmission88021 should make it clear IEEE retains copyright of all material in 8802x standardsComment? IEEEownsthecopyrightofstandardsbuthasallowedISO/IECtopublishthemas8802xstandardsNBstopublishthemasnationalstandards? However,88021isunclearaboutcopyrightissuesbecauseit:– Doesn’taddresscopyrightifthe88021endorsementprocessisused– SuggestsapprovalusingaJTC1FastTrackballotmightrequireacopyrightrelease? ThiscausedsomedifficultyduringtheWAPIdebatebecause:– SomeclaimedIEEEretainscopyrightofstandards,notingrecent8802xstandardshave“Copyright169。yearIEEE”oneverypage,concludingthatJTC1couldn’tamend880211withoutpermission– OthersclaimedthatISO/IECownedthecopyrightsocouldamend880211Proposed resolution ? 88021shouldbemodifiedtomakeitclearthatIEEEownsthecopyrightforthematerialinany8802xstandardbasedonanstandard? Assuming802beestheauthorityforallchangesto8802xstandards,thereisnoneedforISO/IECtoownthecopyrightforany8802xstandardsConclusion–802CopyrightSeptember202323 AndrewMyles(Cisco)doc:IEEESubmission88021 should clarify the IPR situation for 8802x standards derived from standardsComment? DuringtheWAPIdebate,theissueofIPRforan8802xstandardthatisnotthesameasanstandardwasraised? Ifan8802xstandardincorporatesanunmodifiedstandardthenimplementationsbuilttoconformtothe8802xstandardwill,bydefinition,alsoconformtothestandard? LoAssubmittedwithrespecttothecanbeinvokedforthisimplementationonlybecauseofitsconformanceto? If8802xincorporatesonlyinpart,ormodifiesitinanywaythenan8802ximplementationwillnotnecessarilyconformto? LoAsprovidedtoIEEESAcannotbeinvokedforthisimplementationProposed resolution? ThesimplestsolutionisforISO/IECtonotchangeanystandardswhenapprovingthemas8802xstandards? IftheISO/IECdiddecidetochangeanstandard(assumingcopyrightissueswereresolved)then88021shoulddescribetheissuesrelatedtoastandardforwhichthereareknownIPRencumbrances? TheIEEEwouldprobablynotbeabletoassistinobtainingLoA’sforany8802xversionofanstandardConclusion–802IPRSeptember202324 AndrewMyles(Cisco)doc:IEEESubmission88021 should specify that 8802x standards are not limited to LAN technologyComment? 88021ismostlywrittenundertheassumptionthat802onlydevelopsLANstandards– Thetitleis“Part1:OverviewofLocalAreaNetworkStandards”– TherearesomereferencetoMANs– Note:interestinglywasincludedasaLANyetitwasalwaysaMAN? Whilethismayhavebeentruetosomedegreeatthetime,itisnolongerthecase? 802nowdevelopsarangeofwiredwirelesslayer12standardsforPANs,LANs,MANs,RANs,WANsProposed resolution? 88021shouldberewrittentoallow802tosubmitanystandardforISO/IECstandardisation,notjustthoserelatedtoLANs? Ofcourse,SC6shouldhaveavetoonwhethersuchasubmissionshouldbeacceptedasan8802xstandardConclusion–802LANsSeptember202325 AndrewMyles(Cisco)doc:IEEESubmission88021 should not contain any technical materialComment? Muchofthetechnicalmaterialin88021iseitherincorrect,inpleteoroutofdate– eg,Figure1167。includeareferenceto,whichisnowdisbanded? Thiswillbeanongoingproblemasthereislittleincentiveforanyonetoupdatesuchmaterial? SomeofthetechnicalmaterialrelatestoFDDI,whichisnotan802standardsoisnotrelevanttoanagreementbetweenSC6802Proposed resolution? Removealltechnicalmaterialfrom88021,including:– Partsof167。1,167。3– Allof167。5,167。6,167。7,167。8167。9Conclusion–802–TechnicalmaterialSeptember202326 AndrewMyles(Cisco)doc:IEEESubmission謝謝觀看 /歡迎下載BY FAITH I MEAN A VISION OF GOOD ONE CHERISHES AND THE ENTHUSIASM THAT PUSHES ONE TO SEEK ITS FULFILLMENT REGARDLESS OF OBSTACLES. BY FAITH I BY FAI