【正文】
(dissertation) ? Conceptual: Peng Heath (1996 AMR) Peng Ilinitch (1998 JIBS) Peng (2023 AMR) Peng, Lee, Wang (2023 AMR) Trabold (2023 JIBS) – A test of Meyer Peng (2023 JIBS) Peng Ilinitch Lee, Peng, Barney (2023 AMR) Peng, Wang, Jiang (2023 JIBS) ? Qualitative: Peng (1997 OS) Peng, Hill, Wang (2023 JMS) ? Quantitative: Luo Peng (1999 JIBS) Peng York (2023 JIBS) Peng Luo (2023 AMJ) Tan Peng (2023 SMJ) Peng, Zhou, York (2023 JWB) Peng (2023 SMJ) A replication of Trabold Tong, Reuer, Peng (2023 AMJ) Peng, Zhang, Li (2023 MOR) ? Research book: Peng (2023 Sage) Peng (1998 Quorum) ? Practitioner: Peng (1997 CBR。 Mike W. Peng 2023/2/13 11 Data issues ? Qualitative: Peng (1997 OS) ? Quantitative/survey: Luo Peng (1999 JIBS)。 Mike W. Peng 2023/2/13 14 Research implementation ? A wellcrafted article – Tells a good story: Beginning, middle, and end – Draws the reader into the plot – Shows a picture (worth 1,000 words?) ? Standard format, although boring, simplifies our task (and life!) – Qualitative studies may appear to be relatively easier to conduct, but are a lot harder to write Strategy/OT research 169。 Mike W. Peng 2023/2/13 20 The reviewer’s perspective (I) ? I have served on the editorial boards of AMJ, AMR, JIBS, and SMJ, and guest edited a JMS Special Issue ? EditorinChief of Asia Pacific Journal of Management ? Is the story interesting? – Avoid ―dead end‖ topics ? Is the theory sound? – Topic or datadriven versus theorydriven research – Building on previous theory? – Overlooking major aspects of previous work (such as my work)? – Citing authors (such as the reviewer!) correctly? Strategy/OT research 169。 Mike W. Peng 2023/2/13 27 Useful references ? The Elements of Style, Fourth Edition. Strunk, White, and Angell, 2023. Longman ? The Craft of Research. Booth, Colomb, and Williams, 1995. University of Chicago Press, Chicago ? Bird by Bird: Some Instructions on Writing and Life. Anne Lamott, 1995. First Anchor Books ? Writing for Social Scientists: How to Start and Finish Your Thesis, Book, or Article. Howard S. Becker, 1986. University Of Chicago Press. ? The Chicago Manual of Style. By University of Chicago Press Staff, 2023. ? Publishing in the Organizational Sciences. Cummings and Frost, 1995. Sage Publications. Strategy/OT research 169。 Mike W. Peng 2023/2/13 23 Surviving the review process ? Thick skin is required: Everybody gets rejections – 90% rejection rates, my 40+ articles would have been submitted 400 times (baptism by fire?) – I’m now 3 times better than average, which means my submissions are still being killed 70% of the times! ? Realize reviewers and editors are rational – At least in most cases: Everybody can have a bad day – Our intellectual market for ideas is not perfect, but is ra